Where this idea comes from· The Rhind papyrus (about 1550 BCE) · Swift (1726) · Borges (1946)
Pefsu: the baker’s ratio
The Rhind papyrus was copied by a scribe named Ahmes in Egypt around 1550 BCE, from an older book. It is now in the British Museum. Ten of its problems, numbers 69 to 78, are about pefsu: how many loaves of bread, or jugs of beer, one hekat of grain makes.
One thing to hold: A hekat of grain, a dry measure of about 4.8 litres: roughly a big jug of wheat.
Why it matters: Pefsu is a ratio: loaves for every hekat. More loaves from the same grain means smaller, weaker loaves, so a fair trade keeps the grain the same. In one problem 100 loaves of pefsu 10 are traded for loaves of pefsu 45: the same 10 hekat of grain makes 450.
What we don’t know: Nobody knows exactly how big a loaf was, so we cannot bake a pefsu 10 loaf today and be sure it matches.
Gulliver’s dinner
Jonathan Swift’s Gulliver’s Travels came out in London in 1726. In its first part, Gulliver is shipwrecked in Lilliput, where the people are about one twelfth of his height.
One thing to hold: The Lilliputians measure him with a quadrant, an instrument for measuring heights, to work out how much food to give him each day.
Why it matters: They reason that he is twelve times as tall, as wide and as thick as they are, so his body holds many of theirs, and he should get that many people’s food. Growing a body by 12 in every direction multiplies its size by 12 × 12 × 12.
What we don’t know: Nobody knows whether Swift’s number was a joke on purpose or a slip.
In the book’s words:
mine must contain at least 1724 of theirs
Work out 12 × 12 × 12. Did the Lilliputians’ mathematicians get it right?
A map as big as the land
In 1946 the Argentine writer Jorge Luis Borges published a story one paragraph long, “Del rigor en la ciencia” (“On Exactitude in Science”). He pretended it was copied from a travel book of 1658.
One thing to hold: In the story, mapmakers draw a map of the Empire that is as big as the Empire itself, matching it point for point. Later people find it useless and leave it to the sun and rain.
Why it matters: A map the size of the land cannot be carried or seen whole. A map works because every distance is shrunk by the same scale, so one centimetre can stand for many kilometres.
Dates:
- 1893 Lewis Carroll tells the same joke in Sylvie and Bruno Concluded: a map at the scale of a mile to the mile.
- 1946 Borges publishes “Del rigor en la ciencia”.
Common Core standards this practises
- 6.RP.A.3 ratio reasoning in real problems
- 7.G.A.1 scale drawings and maps