HatDojo
The study group
- Dalia writes the plan: the rule each person will follow.
- Jun runs the plan ten thousand times and reports what happened.
- Leilani reads the back person's word as a one-bit check.
- Vikram is working on the hundred-boxes puzzle, which comes later.
A case · you decide
Dalia and the worst line
Dalia & Jun & Leilani — a seventeen-year-old who runs her school puzzle club
Ten club members will stand in a line wearing red or blue hats. Each sees the hats in front, hears the words behind, and says one colour. Dalia has ten minutes to agree a plan.
Her first plan is simple: everyone says red. Jun runs it ten thousand times on his laptop. On average five are saved.
Then Jun scrolls to the bottom of the results. On some lines nobody is saved at all.
How should the club judge a plan?
Leilani suggests the back person gives up on their own hat. What should that one word carry?
The back person is still right only half the time. The plan does not beat chance for them; it moves all the chance onto one person.