Skip the menu
Spark & Anvil Privacy

ConcordQuest

The table

  • Seraphine states the other side better than its owner.
  • Torvald writes down in advance what would change his mind.
  • Ilsabet signs only sentences both sides accept.
  • Ezekiel keeps a fixed study that answers the same way every run.

A case · you decide

Seraphine, Torvald and the homework study

Seraphine & Torvald — a seventeen-year-old on the student council

The idea in play: stating the other side’s view better than its owner, before the evidence comes in.

The council is split on whether to ask teachers for less homework. Seraphine thinks homework helps; Torvald thinks it does not. Last term the argument went round in circles for an hour.

This time they agree on a rule first: each of them says the other’s best reason, and each writes down what result would change their mind.

Torvald writes: “If students with the same grades last year still do better with more homework at every step, I will change my mind.”

Which is Torvald’s strongest reason, said the way he would say it?

The study shows a raw gap of 16 points that shrinks to 4 when students are matched on last year’s grades, and stops after 90 minutes. What goes in the joint report?

Disagree well, together →

What next? Pick a door

Chosen from what this app is about. What you open is remembered on this device only.