SchemeDojo
The dojo
- Clementine names which kind of argument it is.
- Benedek asks the one question that could sink it.
- Saoirse lets a good argument stand.
- Merrow calls everything a fallacy, and pays for it.
A case · you decide
Benedek and the doctor on the poster
Benedek & Merrow — a seventeen-year-old on the school debate team
A poster in the corridor says: “Dr Vance says energy drinks sharpen your focus for exams.” Merrow says it is a fallacy, an appeal to authority, and wants it taken down.
Benedek looks up Dr Vance. She has a doctorate in dentistry. The poster was paid for by a drinks company.
He also remembers last term’s poster from the school nurse about sleep before exams. Merrow called that one a fallacy too.
Which critical question sinks the energy-drink poster?
Merrow says the nurse’s sleep poster is the same fallacy. Is it?
Benedek takes down one poster and leaves the other. Merrow grumbles that it would be simpler to distrust everything. It would also throw out sound arguments half the time.
How are you feeling?
What next? Pick a door
- More like this MaskDojo Did the vote follow a reason? ConcordQuest What result would change your mind? HatDojo Which plan always saves nine of ten?
- A bit harder ClassicsForge Why was this move immortal? SeminarQuest What question opens the seminar? AgoraQuest What would the other side say best?
- Something different FeelDojo Does this answer you, or bait you? QueryForge Which rows will this query return? CommonForge Who owns this knowledge?