Skip the menu
Spark & Anvil Privacy

SchemeDojo

The dojo

  • Clementine names which kind of argument it is.
  • Benedek asks the one question that could sink it.
  • Saoirse lets a good argument stand.
  • Merrow calls everything a fallacy, and pays for it.

A case · you decide

Benedek and the doctor on the poster

Benedek & Merrow — a seventeen-year-old on the school debate team

The idea in play: asking the one critical question that could sink an argument, and letting it stand when none does.

A poster in the corridor says: “Dr Vance says energy drinks sharpen your focus for exams.” Merrow says it is a fallacy, an appeal to authority, and wants it taken down.

Benedek looks up Dr Vance. She has a doctorate in dentistry. The poster was paid for by a drinks company.

He also remembers last term’s poster from the school nurse about sleep before exams. Merrow called that one a fallacy too.

Which critical question sinks the energy-drink poster?

Merrow says the nurse’s sleep poster is the same fallacy. Is it?

Try the argument set →

What next? Pick a door

Chosen from what this app is about. What you open is remembered on this device only.